Understanding the word "NO"

[critter crazy]

There is a chance that they could understand the word no, but Personally I just think they understand the change of tone in your voice.

[StarandBratsmom]

There is a chance that they could understand the word no, but Personally I just think they understand the change of tone in your voice.

You have a point there Maggie. Maybe it's the tone. I am not sure, Star responds to the word "treat," even if I whisper it. I am going to test this tone theory out.

Results:

Situation:

My boyfrined is sitting in the same room on his computer. I am on my computer. Star is dead asleep on the floor between us.

The Test:

I asked, "Honey have you heard about the treats lately?" in the most normal monotone voice, with no special pauses for any of the words. Star wakes up right away from her dead sleep as the response for the word, "treat."

As for the word, "No." Maybe the tone of my voice says not to do it. Who knows. As my boyfriend thinks, Star's spoiled, she doesn't ever hear the word no.

[Tubby & Peanut's Mom]

This thread hits home because I was just saying to CJ last night how I know he knows what I mean, but he keeps at it anyway!

Since we've been taking him on his outies several times a day lately, he thinks he should be out ALL the time. He will sit by the door and meow incessantly until 1) we take him out, 2) I can't stand it anymore and have to yell at him or 3) he finally gets the idea that us ignoring him means he won't be going out and he goes sulking off to the bedroom.

#2 is where the "NO!" comes in. I tried with all the explanations but finally realized he doesn't have a clue what I'm saying, so I started with just plain ol' "NO!" He completely ignores me so I say it again.....and the meowing continues. It's finally gotten to the point where "NO!" means nothing, but snapping my fingers or clapping my hands will make him at least close his mouth for a second and look at me.......

I know he knows what I mean because he is not stupid, and, as a matter of fact, is too smart for his own good most times.

[RICHARD]

IT'S ALL THE PARENT'S FAULT-

EXAMPLE?


My cat's name is Edward D "No!" Katz.


Now,


When I switch his middle name with his first name,
"No! Edward" He doesn't listen.
or
"No!" On it's own, does not work!


I think it's a matter of being consistent.

[heidiv]

It doesn't work at our house I think its parcially my fault from doing to much no!! as kittens. The only one out the bunch that understands it is Tuck he was one of those naughty little kittens that would push every button till you were nutz~ so now today he listens very well. As for the Meezer sisters I can't tell you how Tuck broke his parents down cause I can not look into the blue eyes of those two girls and say no......Chloe is constantly sitting by my side during dinner giving me that sweet Meezer face (cause she knows it works...) I always say in a soft soft voice No, No, Low, Low!!!! And she backs off a bit then at this point she backs off still enduringly looking into my eyes she slowly tries again.....And again I say "No, No Low,Low" And this continues for some time until I have had enough to eat and just give her a little try as I go to put my dishes away...... They ALWAYS win at my house

[StarandBratsmom]

Well I though Star knew what, "NO" meant. She went after a frog this weekend and of course I got onto her. "NO!" I hollered. She didn't listen. I had to go and grab her, despite my insane fear of frogs and let the frog hop away. Star was so mad at me even until this morning. She forgave me though this afternoon.

[kitten645]

Calvin thinks his name is CalvinNo. He can be the naughtiest. However I do believe they understand words. I've tried saying the same words in different ways and generally get the same reaction. So far he understands:
treats (no explaination needed)
flippa flip (where he does a semi tumble and flips left and right on his back..pretty hilarious
lie down (he doesn't ALWAYS do this but usually relents)
What's that? ( as in there's a bird/squirrel on the patio. I can say it from the bedroom and he'll fly to the sliding glass doors to take a look)
Where's Hobbes? (he'll go to wherever his brother is. If he doesn't know he'll look for him)
Mousie (he'll go get a mouse from his toybox if he wants too)

I think some understand more than others and some don't let on they know perfectly well what you are talking about! Isn't there that saying "If cats could talk, they wouldn't"!
Claudia

[momcat]

Since I've been owned by Groucho, I've come to believe that our kitties are very intelligent and understand more than we think they do. With my little guy a stern "no" works..... some of the time. After all, he is a cat!