Those were some very key letters. Someone should be able to figure it out now.

Ho- -an- legs does a dog -a-e i- -o- -all the tail a leg?
-o-r. -alling a tail a leg doesn't -a-e it a leg.
A-raha- Lin-oln

Letters to guess:
BC FG JK M PQ UVWXYZ

Karen 9Es + 5Ts = 23
shepgirl 15As = 30
AmberLee 6Is + 12Ls = 24
Killearn Kitties 3Ss = 3
Miss Z 2Rs = 2
ChrisH 5Ns + 7Os + 6Gs = 25
Almita 3Hs + 3Ds = 6