Here are everyone's letters:

--- -a-- -e-s --es a --- -a-e i- --- -a-- --e -ai- a -e-?
---r. -a--i-- a -ai- a -e- --es-'- -a-e i- a -e-.
A-ra-a- -i-----

Letters to guess:
BCD FGH JKLMNOPQ TUVWXYZ

Karen 9Es = 18
shepgirl 15As = 30
Amber 6Is = 12
Killearn Kitties 3Ss = 3
Miss Z 2Rs = 2