Here are everyone's letters:

T-e I-te--et is a -ia-t i-te--atio-a- -et-o-- o- i-te--i-e-t,
i--o-me- -om--te- e-t--siasts, -- --i-- I mea-, "-eo--e -it-o-t -i-es."
-e -o-'t -a-e. -e -a-e ea-- ot-e-.
~ -a-e -a---

Letters left to guess:
BCDFGHJKLNPQRUVWXYZ

Scores:
AmberLee 21E=42

Karen 11A=22

Killearn Kitties 16T + 5s=21

Pitc9 3M=3

Randi 13I=26

ILoveMyAbbyGirl 9O=18