Not a bad choice at all.

I --st -o-'t li-e -ei-- -a-e to loo- ri-i--lo-s.
It's -o -se -o-r sta--i-- t-ere -alli--,
"-itt-, -itt-, -itt-!"
Or o--eri-- -e -ri-es.
-o-r -oarse la---ter
-as o--e--e- -e -ee-l-
A-- it -a- ta-e -e so-e ti-e to -et o-er it,
Or -e-er.
I- a-- --e- I -o-e -a-- at all
It -ill -e
I- -- o-- s-eet ti-e.

~ -a-l -alli-o

Moesha A(15)+O(19)+L(14) = 82
lvpets2002 E(30) = 60
Karen I(23)+R(12) = 58
The Duck S(10) = 10
Amberlee T(23) = 23

Letters remaining:
BCD FGH JK MN PQRSTUVWXYZ