Last week my husband and I were sitting in the den discussing how we were going to deal with a mouse that was frequenting our kitchen late at night!! We were not in agreement on how to handle it. He wanted to get a pest guy in and I wanted to block off any possible openings the mouse could have been accessing. Just as we started to argue, Sneakers calmly walked into the den with 'the mouse' in her mouth! Problem solved. I felt badly for the mouse though but at least it was quick! We promptly put the 'body' in the woods.
Sounds like your Brody is quite the hunter!!! He must be bringing all these treasures in just for you to thank you for giving him such a good home.