Keegan and my other dog Shai loved them.
I swore by them with Shai.
Keegan doesn't really need them as bad, and I can't imagine that Nebo would need them either due to his age.
They are a mess tho. It says to give them in an easy to clean area.
I accidently swept a peice of it up in my sweeper and my dad had to use the air hose to get it out and after it shot across the driveway, half of a dog biscuit came out !!!!!!!!!!! I don't have any idea when I swept either of them up!!!