No, I am not mixing them.

I was quite happy with Chicken Soup for all the pets. I used it for almost 9 months.

My cat Bobby has LOT of food allergies. When I was doing the food trials to find something he can eat, I came across the Raw Instinct. I just changed the whole house to make feeding times easier for me. Didn't work. Bobby is allergic to all grains, fish and chicken.

He is now on a prescription food, Royal Canin Green Pea and Venison. It works, he has finally stopped itching! It is expensive and I didn't switch the whole house. I have to put him in one bedroom, close the door, get his food for him. Then feed all the others, cats and dogs. After 10 to 15 minutes, I pick up all the dishes, let the dogs snuffle up any cat food remains, then let Bobby out. Even one piece of kibble makes him break out in the itchies, poor boy!

I will probably go back to the Chicken Soup as it costs less than the Raw Instinct, is at a store I can get to more easily, and everyone was fine on it. But it is nice to know it is out there. Oh, the Raw Instinct is coming out with a rabbit meal dry kibble formual after January 1st; it is up on the web site already.