My cats are on regular Innova and they love it. They also look great, people have commented on how amazing their coats look and feel. When Corkscrew was getting over his fatty liver disease and was finally starting to show an interest in food I decided to let him pick out what he wanted to eat. I offered him many different dry foods to eat and he chose Innova so I stuck with it. They are both great foods in my opinion. I also choose to free feed and it seems to work well for us.