None of my dogs particularly like it. They will play in the first couple of snows of the year, then they are pretty much over it. Not sure what the puppies will do, this is their first winter. And Pepper HATES it. If there is more than a dusting of snow, she will pee in the middle of the kitchen floor, a few feet from the dog door, preferably with me watching so she can GLARE at me while doing it. She is SURE I put that cold wet stuff out there, and she wants me to get it OUT of her yard.