Puzzle # 373

[pitc9]

I know that writer!

Me too!

[AmberLee]

--en I A- An O-d -at

--en I a- an o-d -at I s-a-- -ea- a dia-ond -o--a- and -ea-e -- -a---ints on --ite -ou--es. I s-a-- d-ink -- --ea- -it- a tou-- o- --and- and s-it out -- -ita-ins; I s-a-- sit on t-e -a-s o- do- -eo--e -ust to i--itate t-e-; I s-a-- na- on to- o- t-e nei---o-'s -etunias and -e--- on to- o- -i-d-at-s and --o- --a--i---- --u---.

...

Aut-o- Unkno-n

Letters to choose from:
.BC..FGH.J.LM..PQR...VWXYZ

Mina's Momma A (30) = 60 points
Catty1 E (17) = 34 points
Karen I (20) = 40 points
Killearn Kitties O (23), S (13) = 59 points
Randi N (25), T (16) = 41 points
Pitc9 U (8) = 16 points
Cincy's Mom K (2) = 2 points
Miss Z D (14) = 14 points

~~~
Sorry, Karen, N was already chosen. Please guess again.

[Randi]

L, please!

[AmberLee]

--en I A- An Old -at

--en I a- an old -at I s-all -ea- a dia-ond -olla- and lea-e -- -a---ints on --ite -ou--es. I s-all d-ink -- --ea- -it- a tou-- o- --and- and s-it out -- -ita-ins; I s-all sit on t-e la-s o- do- -eo-le -ust to i--itate t-e-; I s-all na- on to- o- t-e nei---o-'s -etunias and -e--- on to- o- -i-d-at-s and --o- --a--i--l- --u---.

...

Aut-o- Unkno-n

Letters to choose from:
.BC..FGH.J..M..PQR...VWXYZ

Mina's Momma A (30) = 60 points
Catty1 E (17) = 34 points
Karen I (20) = 40 points
Killearn Kitties O (23), S (13) = 59 points
Randi N (25), T (16), L (15) = 56 points
Pitc9 U (8) = 16 points
Cincy's Mom K (2) = 2 points
Miss Z D (14) = 14 points

[Cincy'sMom]

W, please

[AmberLee]

W-en I A- An Old -at

W-en I a- an old -at I s-all wea- a dia-ond -olla- and lea-e -- -aw--ints on w-ite -ou--es. I s-all d-ink -- --ea- wit- a tou-- o- --and- and s-it out -- -ita-ins; I s-all sit on t-e la-s o- do- -eo-le -ust to i--itate t-e-; I s-all na- on to- o- t-e nei---o-'s -etunias and -e--- on to- o- -i-d-at-s and --ow --a--i--l- --u---.

...

Aut-o- Unknown

Letters to choose from:
.BC..FGH.J..M..PQR...V.XYZ

Mina's Momma A (30) = 60 points
Catty1 E (17) = 34 points
Karen I (20) = 40 points
Killearn Kitties O (23), S (13) = 59 points
Randi N (25), T (16), L (15) = 56 points
Pitc9 U (8) = 16 points
Cincy's Mom K (2), W (8) = 10 points
Miss Z D (14) = 14 points

[Randi]

I think I have it! Good one Amberlee! Will send a PM with my guess.

Edit* I'm off to bed, but in case my guess is right, I don't mind someone else hosting the next.