You can do it! I have cast all along the "pilling scale" -- Pouncer is the poster child for being easy to pill. Allen is impossible.... even if I swear he's swallowed the pill after a 20 minute struggle, I find the pill sitting on the carpet somewhere about an hour later. The other 3 fall somewhere in between, with Abby a close second to Allen. I swear both Abby and Allen can tap into my mind and know when I'm even thinking about giving them their next pill.