I'm so sorry to hear about Magic. Please forgive me but I don't remember what happened to Panther. Did your vet give a diagnosis? Do they think it is the same thing with Magic?
I do understand how you feel about the endless testing that often doesn't lead to any results. I'm thankful that I have a vet who doesn't like to rush into too many tests at once.
What you are describing reminds me of a very bad time Ripley suffered about 5 years ago. We had just brought Jazz in as a kitten and she had a very bad URI. Ripley caught it and ended up in at the vet for three days on IV antibiotic and fluids. He came home on Saturday and by late Sunday night he began throwing up and having uncontrollable diarrhea to the point that everything coming out was bloody. We rushed him to the vet and it was touch and go for a couple of days. After many tests and x-rays the vet decided it was a secondary infection of the blood stream that was triggered by the few days of antibiotics to treat the URI. Even after he came home I had to take him back every day for a week for an antibiotic injection.
Now we are dealing with Ripley's kidney failure and on his last visit to the vet there were some signs of a possible liver tumor but after talking to the vet we are just waiting to see if anything changes because for the moment he is maintaining.
I'm not sure if telling you Ripley's story will help you at all but I wanted you to know that I understand how you feel. Prayers and positive thoughts for Magic and you.
Bookmarks