Copyright Infringment. What would you do?

[Romance]

I think she should report it but i also think that she should be warned that if it were to come about that Nichole was wrong in her reporting that she could set herself up for a lawsuit and criminal charges for placing a false complaint. Nichole should be very careful in making sure she knows 100% that her complaint is valid.

[jackie]

I think she should report it but i also think that she should be warned that if it were to come about that Nichole was wrong in her reporting that she could set herself up for a lawsuit and criminal charges for placing a false complaint. Nichole should be very careful in making sure she knows 100% that her complaint is valid.

That is true, but if I was in her shoes, I wouldn't "report it" as much a just send a link or copy of the article.

[Romance]

ahhh ok. yes that would keep her from accidentally stepping in it.

[flip195]

This thing about copyright always bugs the hell out of me.
If it is an article the fact is that there are only so many discriptive words in the english language, and sooner or later, if your putting your stuff out on the internet your are going to run across someone who has the same writing style and uses the same words.
If it is an informative article that benefits ppl why not share it, and if your not making oodles of cash from it whats the big deal.

I recently ran into this copyright crap regarding 2 things.
My grandmother was a through and through dog person and was also into home remedies.
Most of you have heard of Blue powder ear treatment, well I have the original mix written in my grandmother recipe book, which was written 30 years ago, yet someone on the internet has added bits and pieces of info to that original recipe and is now claiming it as their own.

My grandmother also passed down a recipe for cat urine removal which contains hydrogen peroxide, washing up liquid, and baking powder, this recipe is also all over the internet with ppl claiming it as their own.

What is more a lot of ppl are selling these recipes for a lot of money because they actually work, so do I claim copyright, the recipe book is dated 1969, and the recipes are handwritten in it, I an prove they are the originals.

Ppl really need to get over this legal crap and start sharing to improve life for others.

Here is a copy of my email regarding the ear treatment (btw that is what my grandmother called it)

Subject: Re blue powder ear treatment.

I have to say I am disappointed by your actions of copyrighting the use of
this formula to stictly printed use as most ppl correspond via email these
days.
Infact I think it is very sad that you have copyrighted the formula at
all.
I have been aware of this mixture for in excess of 30 years, infact I
think I still have the piece of paper my grandmother wrote it on
somewhere in her old recipe book.
This is a treatment that old school dog ppl have known about for years,
shame that you should claim it as your own.
I have found out today you are contacting websites displaying the formula
threatening to sue etc if it is not removed.
Very sad day indeed.
At the end of the day the animals will suffer.

[flip195]

Here is the reply I got


My Web Site, is non-commercial and provides an
ENORMOUS amount of helpful information -- available to all on the internet.
It was a
great deal of work to create this Web Site and all at my own expense. I
hope you'll spend some time reading the wide array of information available
and reconsider your harsh judgment of me.

Please understand that anything authored and PUBLISHED in print (a book with
the copyright stated) -- or on the internet (Web Page) is, by definition,
Intellectual Property and is COPYRIGHTED material, protected by law.

FYI, as I state in my Blue Power Ear Treatment excerpt, the ingredients and
only some of the instructions were given to me more than a decade ago --
for the purpose of publishing it -- in order to let dog lovers all over the
world know about this wonderful remedy. The majority of the Blue Power Ear
Treatment excerpt from my book (10 pages) is from my own research -- along
with responses from users of the remedy.

As medical science evolves, we find better ways to deal with health problems
and that's the case with the Blue Power Ear Treatment. Therefore, the
outdated versions of my work MUST be removed because they omit the updated
information, especially the CAUTION -- of putting anything into an ear canal
without first having a veterinarian verifying that the eardrum is intact.
Otherwise serious problems can result -- causing HARM to the animal!

For the record, I did NOT threaten to sue anyone about this issue. I simply
requested my OUTDATED article be removed and the Link inserted -- so that
all dog lovers may be better informed (with the CAUTION), and FREELY
print-out my article for their personal use at this Link:


Unfortunately, people make false statements, disparaging others unfairly,
and the _misinformation_ continues to circulate quickly via the internet,
for example: on a forum -- stating that my article is "based upon my
experience with the product", to the incorrect remark that I am "promoting
and selling the product" -- which are TOTALLY FALSE.

I have made it very clear in my article that I have never used this old-time
remedy-- because my animals have never had ear problems.

Furthermore, I don't sell any products -- nothing is sold from my Web Site
as it is intended for educational purposes, see:

Regards,
Helen

[NicoleLJ]

Thanks all for the responses. It is interesting to see how each person views these types of things. Really makes you think.
Nicole & Sheena & Puppies

[mike001]

FLIP 95---I couldn't have stated it better myself had I tried. I've also had that recipe for ears on hand for yrs and passed it on, never knew where it came from but it did help a lot of friends. I personally only used it twice, long ago, but always kept it, so thank you to your grandmother for this.
You are so right about copyright, so many articles have been published by members that I have read in dog magazines yrs ago, Some members just change a few things and claim it as their own, so big deal, some of these authentic authors are now dead. Most of us know where they originated from in the first place.
Thank you for a real eye opener.