According to the rules, I can only take 5 guesses, so I will only take the first 5, which were R T N L and Y

One -ay you sto--e- at t-e s-elter. you -eren't lookin- -or -e, -ut I -as lookin- -or you. I -oke- -- -a- t-rou-- t-e -ars an- you rea--e- out your -an-. Our souls tou--e- i- t-at -o-ent, t-o -at-s -er-e- into one. -o- -an I t-ank you -or res-uin- -e? --at's t-at? I res-ue- you?

Available letters:
BCDFGHJMPQVWXZ

Randi: O=54 T=18 L=4
Wombat: E=42 S=8 R=12
Karen: A=26 N=12
Almita: U=32
Catty: I=18 Y=8
Reggie: K=4


Oooo, things are taking shape. Shouldn't be too hard now