Medicine Hat girl guilty of first-degree murder *1st post edited

[cali]

there were some letters the girl wrote published in my local paper the other day, the girl was seriously disturbed, and her "teenage hatred" clearly ran much deeper then normal. what bothered me was the girl admitting the she stabbed her bother "only once, and not hard!" and that she also admitted to choking her brother but "only to put him to sleep so he would not hear his parents being murdered downstairs" as if this actually exuses her? she claims that she never meant it seriously, but she was THERE when her family was murdered. she didnt try to stop it, she HELPED. a triple murder is a triple murder, and 12 is old enugh to understand what she is doing.

[Marigold2]

I am sure there is a lot more to come, this story is more complex and there will be undercurrents here. My question at this point is how did the girl get this way? It will be interesting to see the facts. Perhaps as a society we can learn something from this horrible tragedy.

[columbine]

I am sure there is a lot more to come, this story is more complex and there will be undercurrents here. My question at this point is how did the girl get this way? It will be interesting to see the facts. Perhaps as a society we can learn something from this horrible tragedy.

Well, I can see two possibilities.

1) Mental illness is stigmatized - you don't want your schoolmates knowing you're "cuckoo," and you don't want your neighbors knowing your kid is "cuckoo."

2) Medical care is fast becoming a privilege for the rich. Even if she were herded through a high-speed HMO checkup annually, this kid's illness probably wouldn't show up unless her folks heeded the clues, took the plunge, braved the potential ostracism, and had her evaluated for mental illness (most likely at their own expense, as "Managed Care" doesn't encourage diagnostics that might leave them no contractual recourse but to pay for treatment).

Love, Columbine

[Lady's Human]

2) Medical care is fast becoming a privilege for the rich.

But this was in Canada. You know, the wonderful national medical system we are theoretically insane if we don't emulate? EVERYONE gets medical care in Canada, Gratis.

[columbine]

But this was in Canada. You know, the wonderful national medical system we are theoretically insane if we don't emulate? EVERYONE gets medical care in Canada, Gratis.

Even mental health? Wow... I know that at least accessible substance detox programs would be really helpful where I live (Boston).

I do acknowledge that some folks would consider even blatant hatred "teen rebellion" and try to punish it out of their kids, though, whether or not medical care was available. (insert oobleck recipe here)

Love, Columbine

[Marigold2]

There are almost as many possibilites as mental disorders.

1) She could have been molested by her father or close relative.
2) Her parents could be drug users.
3) Her parents could have been drunks.
4) She or her parents could be suffering from depression, obbsessive disorders, multi-personality and the list goes on.

Someone, somewhere failed this girl. Be it the parents, friends, society.
I think it's a little of both. This girl did not go bad in one day. There were signs, there were hurts inflicted and no help came. I have a friend who's daughter was molested by the uncle and mom and dad just couldn't bring themselves to take this girl to therapy. Mom is depressed, dad was ashamed. This poor girl has done so many horrible, unspeakable things. Acting out in pain and confusion. Had she gotten the help she needed her life would be much different now.
Remember this girl is only 12 and at that age adults seem very smart and powerful. If she had a close loving relationship with her parents or another relative this would not have happened. All kids get mad at their parents, lucky most of our kids don't kill us. This isn't a matter of a girl who got mad, this is a matter of pain so deep and so overwelming that she struck out in an equally painful way. No 12 year old dates someone this age unless they cannot relate, respect, confide, in their parent or parents. All of us that have raised girls that age understand how frightened, confused, shy, embrassessed, overwelmed, they are on a daily basis. It is such a time of growth and confusion. One minute they are playing with Barbie's the next they are pushing you away. One minute it's mommy come sit with me and lets watch a movie together and the next hour she is in her room wanting nothing to do with you. Normal behavior but still loving and 12 year olds still come to mom and dad and know we can fix just about anything. At 12 they still sometimes sit on your lap, want tons of hugs and kisses. Request pink cupcakes with lots of sprinkles and ask you to buy them sparkle nail polish. That is normal. Dating a 20 something is not. I believe this girl was hurt by someone, someone she loved and trusted and that trust was so broken that she could no longer go to mom and dad. Did her parents break that trust. Time will tell. The other answer could be deep deep mental illness on her part, if that was the case her parents should have had her in therapy and a restraining order issued for el-creepo.

[jackmilliesmom]

Hello back at you! Now I ask the question again...WHY is this posted. I don't need to be told the obvious. This is the Dog House. I know that. My question is...while I am sure this is a locally interesting story...do you really think there are people on PetTalk for whom this would be an illustrative story???

Or is it just fun to post?

It's interesting and poses questions for parents to ponder!!!!!!!!! If you do not want to read it don't and don't be such a stick in the mud if they were not meant to be printed then the Moderators KAren and Paul will deal with it OK!

[wombat2u2004]

It's interesting and poses questions for parents to ponder!!!!!!!!! If you do not want to read it don't and don't be such a stick in the mud if they were not meant to be printed then the Moderators KAren and Paul will deal with it OK!

Ohhhhhh.....Jo....you're so cute when you're angry.
Wom

[jackmilliesmom]

Gee thanks Wom and I was only moderately angry wait till you see me in full flight I am really cute and adorable in a scary fashion.... By the way are the cookies choc chip and can I have as many as I want??????????????????

[wombat2u2004]

Gee thanks Wom and I was only moderately angry wait till you see me in full flight I am really cute and adorable in a scary fashion.... By the way are the cookies choc chip and can I have as many as I want??????????????????

Yes.....they are choc chip, and yes you can have as many as you want.
Just sign your name on the dotted line of the Standard Dark Side Entry Form carried by my offsider below.
Wom

[jackmilliesmom]

Yes.....they are choc chip, and yes you can have as many as you want.
Just sign your name on the dotted line of the Standard Dark Side Entry Form carried by my offsider below.
Wom

Ok in black or blue ink?

[wombat2u2004]

Ok in black or blue ink?

Black.....it's gotta be dark you know !!!!

[sparks19]

Excuse me? there are cookies being given out and I was not notified?

Wom.... I thought we were friends

[wombat2u2004]

Excuse me? there are cookies being given out and I was not notified?

Wom.... I thought we were friends

If you want cookies, you have to take a walk on the dark side.
But....hasn't Puck already taken you there ????? Then he should be giving you cookies !!!!!
Wom