The problem with those is that they are still giving the correction long after the dog has barked.

The success rate with them is low. Granted, they do work on some dogs.

As far as the safety goes, it all depends on the individual's tolerance to citronella.

Quote Originally Posted by frawri
Has anyone tried this citronella anti bark collar I have heard? Is that stuff ok for the dog? I know of a friend who used it, and she said it worked with in the first day. But is it really safe for the dogs?