Just out of curiosity, what is Squeak's main course food?
She has dry food available at all times, and a half a can of Fancy Feast in the morning, and the other half in the evening. The reason I started giving her the treats in the first place is because they're hairball control, and she HATES hairball medicine. I don't give her the hairball ones all the time. I also give her the ones in the same bag, but without petroleum.