To be honest, I've gone over the topic of dog food and kibble choices so many times that nothing impresses me much anymore. After debate to debate to "agree to disagree's", my only advice is to use what works for you I can't find the ingredient list for it and I suppose the company that makes it is Member's Mark, but it seems like MM is a large company that makes various human and pet products (infant formula and grills, for example ). That said, they probably don't specialize much in dog nutrition and for that I'd be wary. I know it's futile and it doesn't mean much but check to see if has the AAFCO seal. I wouldn't take the AAFCO seal as a sign of quality, but I'm not familiar with the food so at least you'd have some type of reassurance. My point is: Use what works for you, and if Eli likes the food, go for it!

Also, I fed Ivy two bags of Innova Large Breed Puppy until I read more on the realities of HD. Then, I ditched it and started feeding Ivy the same diet as Giselle (and she gets adult kibble + raw).