This is just plain silly!

[lbaker]

Phred, "no-bake" right up your alley *I'm still trying to figure out eatible PlayDoh* with or without ketchup?

[RedHedd]

Phred, "no-bake" right up your alley *I'm still trying to figure out eatible PlayDoh* with or without ketchup?

PlayDoh always was safe to eat, so technically, yes, it is edible. How palatable it would be is another thing, but adding peanut butter sounds like a great idea! Of course, I wouldn't put ketchup on my Playdoh, but on hotdogs - always!