Quote Originally Posted by Sophist
Wow, glad to see a few more people who are willing to look at the other side showed up while I was away. I was starting to get lonely .
Yes, your primary supporter said it was ok because god said so. Sorry, but the bible doesn't count as empirical evidence.

I appreciate your attempts to use logic and research to back your claims...even if I find your ultimate conclusion wrong. I too get annoyed with anecdotal evidence and the feeling that, whoever is willing to argue the longest and the loudest will "win" the debate.

I will admit I'm no expert on seals, or marine life in general. I do however feel that a more eco-friendly (and seal friendly) solution is surely out there for dealing with this "overpopulation." I will attempt to do a little research myself and see if I can't find some good data on this, and I'll check out the links you provided.