We have tried both a Halti and gentle leader. Personally I like the way a gentle leader fits better, but we have a Halti for sadie and I love it. We don't use it as much any more, but when she needs reminded I put it on her, and she stops pulling.

Cincy is another sotry. she has broken a halti and can also get off a gentle leader. She paws at the constantly no matter what. I took time and fed her t on, gave her trats, etc, etc. Still pawed at it. we were concerned becuase she has had eye surgery many months ago, but we don't want to take the chances of her ripping the stiches and getting cherry eye again. I tried a harness and she still pulled horribly. After almost a year of many attempts with differnt techniques and methods, We started her in her third training class last week and at that time decided to try a prong collar. I was sure I was against it, but gave it a shot and she is doing much better. As Doggies said, DO NOT use this unless you have been taught the proper way. I only decided to go to this becuase we have tried everything else and because we were shown how to use and actually allowed to borrow it and try it for a week before we buy it. Cincy has class tonight and I think we are going to go ahead with it. We only sue it when training and if we are walking by other dogs, we put her in a sit stay and change to her regular collar until we get by. I don't want to take any chnces with it.