American Idol

[Daisy and Delilah]

I'm sure I'm not the only one here who is a little surprised tonight. Do we have anybody still watching this show?

I was sure Phil was out tonight with Haley running a close second. I never even thought of Gina! I'm guessing that Phil's military fans kept him on and Haley's good looks kept her on. I didn't think either of them were that bad but somebody had to go.

I guess Sanjaya is going to be the winner. I had a funny feeling that he might go this week but nooooooooooo...............this is ridiculous!!

[GrabaLab]

We are still watching it, and we were surprised that it was Gina that had to go tonight. We kind of think in the end one of top three girls tonight will win, but then again, we are like you, wondering about Sanjaya.

[RedHedd]

I couldn't even watch. I went to the AI website earlier to find out who was booted off. I was surprised it was Gina - I voted for her many times as she had really gotten better over the weeks. Sanjaya really is ruining it and if he wins, the show will be over.

[KittyGurl]

I can't belive this! Gina is SO GOOD! WHY DID SHE GET VOTED OFF!? Sunjaya is ruining the show. Get him off now and the people who are listening to Howard Stern: STOP VOTING FOR SUNJAYA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! YOU ARE RUINING A REALLY GOOD SHOW!

[KittyGurl]

I wish Sunjaya wouold just wuit the show. He isn't a good singer and he knows it! Why waste the time?
I heard that if Sunjaya wins, Simon is quitting the show. If Simon qits the show and Sunjaya wins, AI will be ruined. Half the people I know don't watch the show no more. I'm starting to get bored of it. AI is boring now because all the good people are getting voted off. Gina! Gina was reall good. She was one of my favorites too. She get6s voted off and Sunjaya stays on? That is just wrong!

[Flatcoatluver]

Gina is one of my favorites. I was so angry. Haily, Sanjaya, or Phil should have left. I couldn't belive when they said Haily was safe.

[RedHedd]

So who's going home tonight? I WANT Sanjaya to leave, but I think it might be Haley, Phil or even Lakisha. Jordin and Blake really rocked it for me last night. Blake even had me up dancing, scaring the cats

[momoffuzzyfaces]

I guess Sanjaya is going to be the winner. I had a funny feeling that he might go this week but nooooooooooo...............this is ridiculous!!

If he wins over Melinda or Lakisha or any of the others who can really really sing, I'll never watch any American Idol again!!! Simon has threatened to quit if he wins!!!!

[critter crazy]

Accckkkkk.......No More Sanjaya!! My dog can sing better than him!! I cannot believe that he has made it this far, it is quite depressing!

[Daisy and Delilah]

Seriously, does anybody have any theories or facts on how Sanjaya is staying on this long? I thought AI was stopping the nonsense on votefortheworst.com. Is it still going on? I went to their website and I couldn't figure out where to click to see this charade.

I read somewhere that even his fellow contestants are getting upset with him. They're all very serious about this and he just keeps on keeping on for some reason. Is it really all the young girls that are in love with him voting for him or is there more to it? I guess I'm just in shock and I can't figure out WHY????????? or...........HOW??????????

I'm going to say that it's my last time watching too if he wins. For real. I think this is destroying the whole concept for a lot of people

[GrabaLab]

We heard on a talk radio station that the young girls [ages 12-15] are who mainly votes over/over again and that is how he is staying on and likely to win.

[Taz_Zoee]

Ok, did anybody else hear Sanjaya say last night that he was going to show America that he really could sing. What?? You weren't trying to do that all along?!?!?!
Yeah, I was sad to see Gina go, I thought for sure it'd be Haley. It irks me each week to see Sanjaya hanging in there.

[Lobodeb]

Did anyone watch "Grease, You're the One That I Want?" Well, what they did was similar to AI in that they let America Pick the winner, but with a twist. They would announce the bottom 2, and even say who got the least amount of votes. But then the judges could save that person if they wanted to! I think AI should do that. They're losing a lot of good singers because of that votefortheworst and Howard Stern crap!

In this week's episode it Grease's concept wouldn't have done us any good as far as Sanjaya goes because he wasn't even in the bottom 2.

[dogzr#1]

With as much publicity Sanjaya is getting, I'm not that surprised he's still in there.

I'm sad though that Gina went. I really liked her. I was hoping it was Phil because he just gives me the creeps . Also, I don't think Haley should be there right now. All she does is show her boobs or legs and she gets enough votes by men.