American Idol

[sirrahbed]

How did everyone think Diana Ross sounded? I think she was pretty pitchy and didn't sound great at all.

I noticed this too - I think her voice has lost the power and she sounded like her voice is getting old. But she is still so beautiful and I love her smile.

[Daisy and Delilah]

I agree completely, Debbie. She really looked beautiful but the quality she once had wasn't there. I've always said that they hold those Idol contestants to such extremely high standards on pitch, voice quality, strength, projection, etc. It sometimes seems that they're being too picky when some of the professionals get up there and sound off on all counts
I can't help but wonder what the kids must be thinking when their coach/mentor sounds a little pitchy throughout the song.

No wonder the winners are so successful. They are as close to perfect as it gets.

[Lobodeb]

I would have been happy if any of the bottom 3 got the boot. I don't care for any of them. And add Haley to the list. She's a cutie, but that's about it.

I never cared for Brandon. I couldn't even remember his name before last night.

Sanjaya really needs to go, next.

[pitc9]

......drat... he's still there..... wow.
What the H*LL is wrong with people??
Sanjaya needs to go!!!
I was reading a review yesterday on Yahoo about Sanjaya's perfromance and they said he sounded like a "Gnat after a Tracheotomy"
I was LMAO!!!!

Like I've been saying... there's always next week!

[Lobodeb]

I just checked votefortheworst.com and they're pulling for Sanjaya. That could explain why he's made it so far.

[jazzcat]

I just checked votefortheworst.com and they're pulling for Sanjaya. That could explain why he's made it so far.

I've been following another board that tells what votefortheworst.com is doing. They were pulling for that girl Antonella for the girls and Sanjaya for the boys. Now all the push if for Sanjaya. He is definitely the worst!

I think Haley needs to go too. We can never remember her name but I've nicked named her the "Beauty Pagent Girl" because that is what she reminds me of. I don't care for her very bland voice.

I really like Blake but I thought his version of that song sounded horrible this week. He's much better than that. Oh well, there is only so much you can do with a Diana Ross song in my opinion.

I agree, Diana didn't sound too good. Too bad there isn't something to stop aging on your vocal cords like there is for your skin.

[Lobodeb]

I must have smoked something because I thought Sanjaya actually sounded decent.

Based on the performances, I'd have to say that I think Gina is in trouble. She didn't do well at all. I didn't recognize a lot of the songs, but Gina, La Kesia and Chris R. didn't float my boat.