Quote Originally Posted by GraceByDesign
Yes, this was what I was trying to say! We have only had Dot (16 month boxer/bulldog/hound/?? mix, 50#) for a week, so I have limited experience. It is not my plan for her to have to walk head up all the time. I needed to get some control, and then we could gradually train her to a slack lead.

It was not enjoyable for either of us, when I was being yanked along and she was gagging and choking the whole way. Also with the high collar, she holds her head up. I do not force it up. The short lead is firm so I will maintain control if she tries to start pulling again.

I was just trying to offer a suggestion to the OP that had worked for us, not start a debate on the merits of Cesar's way.

Best of luck!
You forcing a dog to submit to your control is one thing. You training the dog to be willing to submit to your control and enjoy doing it is another. The point isn't about Cesar Millan, but rather about the downsides and cruelness of the old school methods he uses. She holds her head up by herself because of the pressure you are putting on certain places on her neck, so in turn, your still basically forcing it. If you can have the leash literally dragging on the ground it's so slack and she still has her head up like that, then I'll believe she's doing it on her own and you have nothing to do with it.