Leslie,
I am using the Pro Plan Salmon and Rice (made by Purina, but not available in the grocery store) for Butter and Mimi. Mimi eats very little dry food, but Butter LOVES it, and I believe it is very healthy for him. On occasion, Mimi indulges as well. But she mostly eats Fancy Feast......and at her age (13), who am I to force her to eat something she doesn't like or can't chew? She's the boss of this house!
My dogs have been switched from California Natural to Innova Senior because it was next to impossible to get the California Natural in Greenville. Since they are both made by the same company, I'm sure both are good foods.
Logan