The Shredder!

[critter crazy]

You keep the puppy outside the majority of the time, and then wonder why he chews things, and pees in the house. This dog is 5 months old, should be indoors, and be potty trained by now. He was dumped, as you said, but as far as I can tell is still being dumped, by being outside all the time. JMO!

[freckledimple]

I live with and take care of my grandparents(88 & 89), and they will not allow a big dog puppy indoors all the time. They only allow small animals indoors. The only reason they will allow him in during cold nights is because he is a puppy. If this were my home he would be an indoor/outdoor dog, but I have to respect their wishes. I go outside and play with him and give him attention several times a day. He also has a nice big yard to run in and a very nice dog house, and plenty of toys. I cannot go back to my own home until I am finished here. I don't punish him for his behavior, I am only looking for a solution. I came here seeking advice, not criticism; and I would appreciate judgement being withheld if the whole situation is not known.

[Canis-Lupess]

I agree that people shouldn't jump down somebody elses neck too quick just because they keep their dogs outdoors.

Many breeders of dogs who have a larger number of dogs keep their dogs outdoors in kennels etc...because there are just too many to have in the house. You can't call them bad dog owners just because they don't keep them indoors. As long as they go out and give them lots of attention in the day. At night, it makes no difference because, in my opinion, dogs should spend the night alone in their own space, not in the same bed as their owners. This can create over attachment and seperation anxiety, not to mention the dominance issues associated with the dog being allowed into such an important area as on the master bed.

I have to keep mine outdoors because I live with the parents who will not for anything allow them inside except at bonfire and new year because of the fireworks. If I could afford my own place, I would have them in a bit more to spend more time with me but there is nothing I can do about that so I can understand where freckledimple is coming from on this one.

Like her, I do go out and see to them several times a day. I take Jess for 3 or 4 walks each day and she's currently living in the car port next to the house and I bring her into the porch for shorter periods too which is attached to the kitchen because, since Mist died, I hate leaving her alone in the run and she has a light in the car port too for when it gets dark and my stepdad is often out there doing DIY jobs (his work shed is sort of inside the carport) in the daytime so she has him around too.

[sprokett]

I agree that people shouldn't jump down somebody elses neck too quick just because they keep their dogs outdoors.

Many breeders of dogs who have a larger number of dogs keep their dogs outdoors in kennels etc...because there are just too many to have in the house. You can't call them bad dog owners just because they don't keep them indoors. As long as they go out and give them lots of attention in the day. At night, it makes no difference because, in my opinion, dogs should spend the night alone in their own space, not in the same bed as their owners. This can create over attachment and seperation anxiety, not to mention the dominance issues associated with the dog being allowed into such an important area as on the master bed.

I have to keep mine outdoors because I live with the parents who will not for anything allow them inside except at bonfire and new year because of the fireworks. If I could afford my own place, I would have them in a bit more to spend more time with me but there is nothing I can do about that so I can understand where freckledimple is coming from on this one.

Like her, I do go out and see to them several times a day. I take Jess for 3 or 4 walks each day and she's currently living in the car port next to the house and I bring her into the porch for shorter periods too which is attached to the kitchen because, since Mist died, I hate leaving her alone in the run and she has a light in the car port too for when it gets dark and my stepdad is often out there doing DIY jobs (his work shed is sort of inside the carport) in the daytime so she has him around too.

i agree 150%
dogs should not spend the night with theyre owners because of the same reason canislupess

[sprokett]

and why is everybody jumping down freckledimple's neck?????

[critter crazy]

All I am trying to say, is at 5 months old the dog should be potty trained. But being outside, it is hard to potty train a dog. Obviously he is not going to know what to do with potty pads, if he is only allowed to come in once in a while. Training is needed. You cannot expect a dog to just automatically know what to do. they have to be trained.

[gwen]

I'm no expert on dogs but from a purely emotional instinctive reaction I really dont know why people get dogs and keep them outside, my next door neighbours has two and they are permanently outside and when I see them they seem so sad, my dog would be bereft if I left him outside, when he does go in the garden after about 10 minutes he is peering through the window desperate to be let back in. I got my dog to be part of my family, and we live in the house so why wouldn't he? I dont baby my dog and I have 4 children so I dont in anyway confuse him for a child but still, it just seems wrong if he were exiled, no matter how much time you spend in the garden with the dog ultimately you are going to return to the comfort of your home. It just doesnt seem right.

[sprokett]

All I am trying to say, is at 5 months old the dog should be potty trained. But being outside, it is hard to potty train a dog. Obviously he is not going to know what to do with potty pads, if he is only allowed to come in once in a while. Training is needed. You cannot expect a dog to just automatically know what to do. they have to be trained.

i understand he is 5 months old and yes he should be trained but he
hasnt exactly had the best start in life being dumped has he??
but you can say "all im a trying to say ,is at 5 months old the dog should be potty trained" so what if he is outside as long as he get's plenty of exercise and play he will be fine it is just the same being inside or out whilst potty training.And no the dog will not know w/out being trained ,but does not mean you have to jump down freckledimple's throat