Thanks for the ideas. I haven't tried the water bottle, may have to do that. She loves snow but I don't know how much she loves water so that could work...

I can't spray anything on the couch, my parents wouldn't go for that. I tried vinegar already on something she wouldn't leave alone (Nebo's tag holder on his collar), and well, she likes vinegar, she thought it tasted great (crazy dog!).

If she doesn't get the hint soon I may order something like that, but I'm hoping to try some other things first, thanks for the ideas!