Here's the puzzle:

H-- -a- y-- tell i- y--r --- is a -reat -a-e? It's easy!

~Y--r -hil-re- -- l---er ha-e t- -ash their -a-es

~He -al-s y--

~Y-- --y a -hest -reezer --st --r the --- ----

~He -ears y--r T~shirts

Letters to guess:

BCDFGJKMNOPQUVWX

There are 5 L's

Fuzzy317 has 21+8+1=30 points
Dogz has 12 points
AmberLee has 34+12+9=55 points
Piglet has 12 points
LabLoverKEB has 5 points