Rupert hurt my brother.

[Lori Jordan]

Ok,Now you are saying he was almost dead,You are totally turning your story around,

[Alysser]

How was your brother almost dead? You said he only had a scratch above his eye?

[borzoimom]

and no one saw it, and grounded for being on line- now that is ruperts fault too... I am soooooooo confused...

[Catty1]

I think it reasonable to assume that, since she is young herself, and her brother was knocked to the ground with some blood visible (from the cut), it would be a gut reaction to wonder how badly he was hurt. Might even flash thru the mind, 'is he dead'?

I thought Karen's response was apt, and the rest after that are picking nits.

Someone once said to me, "You can be right - or you can be happy."

And I am not right here...this is just my opinion.

hugs to all, and no more whistles around Rupert, ok?

[borzoimom]

yea I could see that reaction in a child. You are right..

[luvofallhorses]

How was your brother almost dead? You said he only had a scratch above his eye?

yeah really!

[MagicForPets]

Oh jeez this is going way too far from my point of view
It's true that your brother couldn't be almost dead from a scratch above his eye, and I believe you are over reacting, which I do sometimes, but why does everyone have to get all worked up about it
And I thought you said Rupert bit your brother, not jumped on him. If he jumped on him that would be a whole nother story...
Also, if your sister was there, did she tell you the story? Your sister, being 8, could have been over reacting. Maybe the dog really was just playing, not viciously trying to kill your brother. Know what I mean?

[luvofallhorses]

I think he just scratched her brother with his paw by accident.

[Lori Jordan]

I think he just scratched her brother with his paw by accident.

You and i both know we will never hear the truth,But as of now and staying away from this post it is all lies,I reall do feel for Rupert and hope he is never put in any other situations.

[Daisy and Delilah]

Warah Girl: I think it would be beneficial to you and everyone here if you try to think before you post on a public board. Calm down first and then open a discussion. Alot of confusion could have been avoided.
When reading something that is written, rather than said, things can be misunderstood and the situation spirals out of control in a very short time. Think before you speak. I would also recommend not posting statements that were made in anger.

I hope your brother is okay. Since the whistle obviously irritates Rupert, please put it away so this won't happen again. Please give Rupert some kisses and hugs from us.