I'm late Katie but of course I voted TAKE THEM!!! I agree that this neighbor is an idiot and she will probably add more but you can at least save these two. Unfortuantely my guess would be that animal control will probably do nothing about the situation. If they have licensing and rabies laws then they might be able to fine her or take the cats if she can't get them rabies shots.

If she comes around questioning you I would just tell her that you told her something would happen if she left them outside unattended all the time! Are you sure she would even notice them missing?? With the things I see, hear, and deal with daily at the shelter I have to tell you I have really grown to dislike most people! I have also discovered that there is very little compassion out there for stray cats. Its really sad.

The good news is....These two little boys are very very lucky!!! I have no doubt that the best thing that could ever happen in their lives just did!!! God Bless you and loads of hugs and kissies to those two cutie pies!