Not So Sure About This Idea

[Catlady711]

This was the only other information I could find on this rottie.

Chopper

[LilacDragon]

One is led to wonder, if Chopper was a Golden Retriever or a Labrador that had accidently bitten it's owner and it had then gone through the training and passed - would we still think it was a bad idea?

[Ginger's Mom]

One is led to wonder, if Chopper was a Golden Retriever or a Labrador that had accidently bitten it's owner and it had then gone through the training and passed - would we still think it was a bad idea?

The answer to that, for me anyway, would definitely be "Yes." It is not the wisdom of training a rottweiller to be a therapy dog that people are questioning (I don't think), but the wisdom of taking a dog around somewhat fragile people that has already inflicted injury on it's owner. I know she says he accidentally bit her, but it also says he ripped tendons and broke several bones, so I wonder if it was really a quick one bite type of thing, or a more prolonged incident.

[areias]

I don't think it's a good idea either. Sounds like a huge risk.

Also, it makes me think that she's not trying to be helpful in the community, but she's trying to show that she can outwit the 'rules and regs', if you know what I mean, and get her name out there.

[BC_MoM]

I believe once a dog has bitten, no matter the circumstances, you have to to keep in mind that it is very possible for your dog to do it again. You need to be aware, and take the appropriate action.

I don't think the nursing home therapy is a good idea.

[Miss Z]

I think the heart of Chopper's owner is in the right place, and I admire her immensely for trying to clear her dog's name. Whether or not the best way to go about doing that is to turn him into a therapy dog, I'm not sure, but really I wish her the best of luck and hopes everything works out for her and Chopper.

One is led to wonder, if Chopper was a Golden Retriever or a Labrador that had accidently bitten it's owner and it had then gone through the training and passed - would we still think it was a bad idea?

The answer to that, for me anyway, would definitely be "Yes." It is not the wisdom of training a rottweiller to be a therapy dog that people are questioning (I don't think), but the wisdom of taking a dog around somewhat fragile people that has already inflicted injury on it's owner. I know she says he accidentally bit her, but it also says he ripped tendons and broke several bones, so I wonder if it was really a quick one bite type of thing, or a more prolonged incident.

I agree with both of you to an extent there. When a dog has bitten before, there is always a thought in the back of your mind that they'll bite again. However, if this was about a labrador, for instance, I don't believe that it would hit the news, it would be more likely to be swept under the carpet and pretended the incident never happened.

[GreyhoundGirl]

I know I wouldn't want to be a patient of any dog that has done that much damage to a human before. ( unless the human did that much damage to it first ) No matter WHAT breed it is.

And remember, I'm not a person who wouldn't want to see a dog. Think how people who aren't really fond of dogs will think.

[Ginger's Mom]

I agree with both of you to an extent there. When a dog has bitten before, there is always a thought in the back of your mind that they'll bite again. However, if this was about a labrador, for instance, I don't believe that it would hit the news, it would be more likely to be swept under the carpet and pretended the incident never happened.

I am not trying to be argumentative here, honest, but I really need to disagree. I believe it is the owner of this dog that is trying to make this a news event, not people who are opposed to Rotties. I had a foster dog who was a biter, I would never have thought of taking her to testing to become a therapy dog (and she was a small dog). I think if this lady wants to improve the status of Rottweillers, there are many ways she could truly help the breed. Taking a dog that has "mauled" her hand to nursing homes is just not the way to do it. And to put that dog and people in that position just for publicity is wrong. People should not be overcome by their desire to improve the the status of Rottweillers that they make bad or questionable decisions. I love Rottweillers, I have never met one that I couldn't walk up to and give them a nice big pet on that lovely big head. But this particular dog should probably not be in a nursing home. It has nothing to do with the breed. I feel sorry for this dog, I think she is using him to make a statement, rather than just enjoying him and letting him be her spoiled pet.

ETA: Buttercup, I just saw your post. This dog didn't just bite her, her broke several bones and tore tendons. There is a difference. Also, I, of course, do not know what caused that attack, but lets just say for the sake of argument one of the older residents lost their balance while going to pet the dog. The dog may see the sudden movement of the person coming at him as threatening. It is just not a good idea for this dog (not saying Rotties in general).