I agree. I think people who rub there dogs faces in there pee should ahev it done to themselves. See if the ylike. I also do not beleave in hitting a dog. My brother hits chewy so he is no longer aloud to play, otuch, talk or look at Chewy till he learns to controlle himself. Which could be years..lol. Well any way. I agree catching him in the act will and a firm no, being taken out side comanded to go potty and then once he goes lots of praise and bring him back in, it will work, give it osme time! Best of luck to you