the stupid thing? its more likley that I am the lucky one that Happy listens so well, not him, Happy was off leash as well as she listens better that way, but if Happy attacked that dog, it would be MY butt on the line, I joked that I should take her by his house with her leashed, and let her go at his dog, perhaps that would teach him a lesson, and he cant lagally do a thing, after all, HIS dog was loose OFF his property, with no collar and mine was on a leash, but that would be mean and sinking to his leval lol