I think if she lied to get her car back it would be a terrible lie but the fact that she lied in concearn for her dog... I think I might have done the same thing. I know everyone here loves their pets, but like me.... and some others, I have no kids. I consider Tinky and Jupiter my kids and I love them more than anything. God forbid, if I was in that lady's situation ... I think I would have considered telling the same lie.. (which for me would have held truth because Tinky is my daughter and Jupiter my son.. in my eyes... ) Some people just don't get the bond we have with our animals and I WOULD GO CRAZY... If I thought I was about to lose one of my two.