Teen seeks alternative to Chemo- Denied

[Corinna]

Ok for once I must disagree with you LH , having been through this kind of stuff with hubby, FDA only wants the drugs that the doctors and researchers can get big kick backs and big bucks from the government. The are cures for many cancers but our gov. and the Canadian gov does not allow them. they evn have gone as far as conviscating all the data and product made by a holistic doc. and her daughter in Cananda . Luckly they had brains enough to keep duplicate formulas in 3 different locations . It is what has kept my hubbys cancer from returning.
Back to the news article , the young man in question is fully understanding of his choices (Cat I really think it is big brother in this case) becouse he does know the results. Let him choose it's not like he beleives every thing the parents say He has done the research.

[sparks19]

And if the story was simply "child dies because alternative treatment fails after parents refused the doctors chemo" (which in reality is what it is because the child has no legal say in the matter) there would be a public outcry.

Well that would be a terrible thing because that is not what happened here. If the story was simply that of course there would be a problem but there is so much more to the story. The fact that he tried Chemo for three months and found it to be too much to bear. He may only be 16 but this kid has gone through some things I hope none of us EVER have to go through.

The parents didn't refuse treatment. the child tried that treatment and decided he could not continue and they decided to seek alternative medicines. I think it's terrible the courts can impose this treatment on him. I thought Torture was illegal? Thats what this is, forcing him to go through the pain he has already decided he cannot take is torture. Plain and simple.

[K9soul]

My personal opinion on this is if the young man and the parents are fully informed on both methods and aware of possible consequences and want to go with the alternative treatment, he should be allowed to do so. At most they could have them sign a form that they are going against medical advice (for lawsuit purposes), but I believe this is too much interference into something that is a personal choice for the family involved. If the young man himself wanted chemo but the parents weren't allowing him and forcing the alternative, that'd be a different situation and I could see legal involvement then.

[lizbud]

"Cancer" Is a catch all used to describe many diseases. For some, chemo is ineffective, for others it is HIGHLY effective. The reason the "alternative" treatment is not offered in the US is probably because it is impossible to prove scientifically that it works. In this case, Hodgkin's disease, it is extremely effective.

Actually Cancer comes in many different forms. Lung cancer is different in
molecular structure than say, Breast cancer.They are all different cancers
and affect different parts of the body.

I really think the boy's chances are better with the Chemo, but I think
the familes wishes should be followed.