How do you pronounce it?

[Barbara]

There is that good old pirate musical (isn't it The Pirate?) with I think Judy Garland where they even have a song that ends like "in the Care ib Bee.. or the Ca RIB ian sea"

[finn's mom]

Both!

[luvofallhorses]

Ka-rib-e-an

[catnapper]

Must be a geographical pronounciation because I only ever hear Ka-rib-be-an.

[Tralee]

I proncounce it both ways.

[dab_20]

I pronounce it both ways, but use Care-a-bee-an more.

[Cataholic]

I hear it both ways and pronounce it both ways!