Thanks so much everybody. I've tried to find the Feline Fresh that Slick mentioned, but no luck. I did find, and I think Donna mentioned, that Feline Pine comes in scoopable form now, but I couldn't find that either.

So I was standing in front of the litter at PetSmart yesterday for almost 1/2 hour, reading and trying to decide which one I wanted to waste my money on to try. I finall decided on a brand called Pa-Purrr or something like that. It's paper, is clumpable and looks and feels like the clay clumpable to the kitties. The only thing I was leery about what the comment "Light Fresh Scent" which I could smell a little bit in the store. I cleaned out one litter box this morning and dumped the Pa-Purrr in - NO dust whatsoever! Whoo hooo! I'm onto something here! Then the "Light Fresh Scent" hit me and I about fell over! Imagine wet old newspapers doused in real stinky perfume...... Hopefully the smell will dissipate a bit as it sits in the box today. Peanut came in, headed right for the box, stopped, tentatively sniffed, tentatively stepped in, then it must have felt normal because she just went about her business and everything seemed find.....until she stepped out of the box and what appeared to be about half the litter in the box came with her on her feet.

So, preliminary indications are this is not the right choice for a permanent solution, but it is dustless, so I'll give it a chance....at least until I can find some of the scoopable pine stuff.

PS - I almost went with the Crystals, but it keeps mentioning silica on the label and for some reason I just don't think silica and kitty innards will mix too well. But it can't be harmful to them or they wouldn't be able to sell it, would they? This is all so confusing.....