American Idol Season 5

[Cincy'sMom]

I think the best thing baout Tayloe winning is that Simon wanted to pass on him. Said American would never vote for him!! Ha-Ha!!

I thought Clay looked weird, but maybe it is just me. It was hilarious to watch the other guys reaction when he came out. A little too excited, maybe?

[RedHedd]

I thought Clay looked weird, but maybe it is just me. It was hilarious to watch the other guys reaction when he came out.

I HATE that Beatle hair-do. Clay's best look for me was when it was red and kinda straight up. But he's still MY American Idol! Can't wait for his new CD!

[Tralee]

Maybe they didn't want any confusion between Clay and the other guy. I thought his hair cut looked nice, its different. Like when Chris was performing with Live I had a little trouble keeping them straight.
Clay and Chris are my american idols!!


Has anyon watched any of the country music award shows? ACM, and CMA. Carrie Underwood won a ton of awards for "Jesus Take the Wheel."

[RedHedd]

Like when Chris was performing with Live I had a little trouble keeping them straight.

Me too! They both looked HOT!

[pitc9]

Soul Patrol Baby!!!
If it wasn't going to be Chris that won, I'm glad it was Taylor! He rocks!
I'm sure we'll be seeing a lot of Kat too, I can see her being a spokeswoman for a makeup company or something. She's so beautiful!!
(Not saying she doesn't have a good voice... I'm just saying she's also beautiful and could also do other things)
Bucky cracks me up!! (just as long as I don't have to hear him sing)
Picker.. she's too much for me. She's an airhead we all know that, but she milks it for all it's worth.
Ace - Has a great smile but needs a haircut IMO!
Paris... ugh... I didn't miss seeing her at ALL! (stuck up little snot!!)
Elliott, I'd buy his CD but wouldn't watch his video's
Chris... Chris... Chris... You can be MY Idol ANY day!!!

[HollandLoppy89]

SOUL PATROL!!!!!
I knew it would be him since the auditions. I would have had the finale be between Elliott and Tay if I had the choice. Kat is so fake to me. Her smile, it seems like it's painted on. Like she isn't enjoying herself. Taylor really does put on a show and I loved his single, "Do I Make You Proud?". Amazing. He is one awesome guy. Can't wait for the tour to hit Detroit!!!

[WolvesRawk]

As much as I love Taylor, I was hoping for Kat or Chris to win. Ah well. I thought Clay looked ADORIBLE with his hair like that. He's normally an ugly geek with a beautiful voice. That other guy was rather creepy. He was literally BOUNCING in his chair! He was like a little girl at a Backstreet Boys concert...Very creepy. Clay is a good person for making that guy so happy instead of it being some cruel joke...