Houston, we have a problem!

[Tubby & Peanut's Mom]

Well...if Bernard's bag was near Maya's feeding spot, and she is the one that pooped outside the box...maybe just get her checked out?

This was my thought too. See if you can collect a urine sample from her because usually a vet who knows your cats will allow you to just bring in the sample for testing - thus avoiding the usuall office call costs.

The only other suggestion would be to isolate them one at a time. Put Bernard's lunch bag in the room with them so the temptation is still there (I'm assuming Bernard will get a new lunch bag anyway ) and see what happens. I know it's hard confining cats who normally have free run of the house, but it could help solve the problem.

Good luck and do keep us informed!

[Maya & Inka's mommy]

See if you can collect a urine sample from her

Oops, I wish I saved some of the pee I found on that bag and on the floor... . How the heck can I get an urine sample now?? Please , tell me