I missed the first songs, so I can't comment on those. The second round Katharine did do better but Taylor still did well. The third round - how cheesy were those songs? Especially Katharine's! I feel sorry for them that they have to sing those. Katharine's singing in that song was a mess to me. The low notes sounded awful and she just didn't seem like she was into it. Taylor blew her away that round!

I think Taylor is our American Idol