American Idol Poll

[joanofark]

http://petoftheday.com/talk/showthre...6&page=1&pp=15

[RobiLee]

Ok, I'll go first in this thread. I have enjoyed both Katharine and Taylor. I wanted Elliott to win this thing, but knew that he wouldn't, so I have always thought that Kat would make the best choice. Tonite I completely flipped and I am voting for Taylor. I think he is fun and I think he can make any song his own. I had also decided that since I like them both I would base my vote on tonite's performances and in my opinion Taylor won.

[petslover]

I loved Taylor's performances tonight. so I have to go for him!!! GO TAYLOR GO!!

[zippy-kat]

This is a tough one as I REALLY like them both! However, I voted Taylor.

Reason being:
If Taylor loses, I think it's the end of the road for him.
If Kat loses, I'm sure someone, somewhere is going to offer a record deal.

*shrug* I'd REALLY like to see them both win this thing! lol

[dab_20]

This is a tough one as I REALLY like them both! However, I voted Taylor.

Reason being:
If Taylor loses, I think it's the end of the road for him.
If Kat loses, I'm sure someone, somewhere is going to offer a record deal.

*shrug* I'd REALLY like to see them both win this thing! lol

I agree!

[lute]

KAT! i've been a Kat fan since day one!

[.sarah]

Taylor is the pick in my house. My mom is down stairs voting for him right now. I keep hearing busy signals but she says she's gotten four votes in so far. First time we've ever voted! We really don't want Kat to win!!!

[shihtzulover850]

This is a tough one as I REALLY like them both! However, I voted Taylor.

Reason being:
If Taylor loses, I think it's the end of the road for him.
If Kat loses, I'm sure someone, somewhere is going to offer a record deal.

*shrug* I'd REALLY like to see them both win this thing! lol

good because sooner or later he is going to come to the end of the road. He just isn't the next american idol!

[Zippy]

The two that are left can't sing

[lute]

good because sooner or later he is going to come to the end of the road. He just isn't the next american idol!

i agree. he's too old to make a big impact on the teenie boppers, which is who listens to the winner after they win. they just don't want to have crushes on a guy with grey hair.

[Flatcoatluver]

But American Idol is NOT about appernece(SP). What happened to personality?? He has a great additude, and in my opinion a great voice.

[zippy-kat]

He just isn't the next american idol!

Oh yes he is! lol



(And -I've forgotten now who said this- grey hair doesn't necessarily mean he's old! He's the same age as Mandisa, one of the other top 12. )

[*iluvskipper*]

Oh yes he is! lol



(And -I've forgotten now who said this- grey hair doesn't necessarily mean he's old! He's the same age as Mandisa, one of the other top 12. )

oh crap he is!!! i don't like him!!! i wanted katherine to win!!!