American Idol Season 5

[caseysmom]

I want to cry, I couldn't help myself I came and looked here before I saw it on the west coast.

I don't even feel like watching next week I don't care for Katherine or Taylor but I hope Taylor wins so Katherine doesn't.

[Daisy and Delilah]

I was very sad last night too. I hate to see Elliot go but I sorta knew it would be him. Kat has a fan base somewhere that's keeping her alive. The voting was so close it was unbelievable. Taylor is another story. In my opinion...he jumps around way to much and sings way too little. When he does sing, he sounds off key most of the time. What is he gonna do as our Idol winner? I do think he's going to win over Kat however so maybe we'll get to find out. I'm like many others, I've never liked him either. He lacks insincerity to me. There's something about that guy that I don't like. Good luck to Elliot in everything he tries to do. A man with tears in his eyes gets me every time

[rosethecopycat]

He lacks insincerity to me.

If this means you think he is sincere, then I agree.

Go Taylor, now that Elliot is gone.

Somewhere over the Rainbow was NOT, by far the best performance of the season. Did you all hear Elliot sing "Moody's mood for Love" again.
That was clearly a superior vocal performance.
Sorry, if it's not a 'well known' song.
We liked all the songs Elliot sang on Tuesday, we know them well.

Taylor please take this thing home now, I'm getting a bit tired of seeing Kat's weepy, doe-eyed father on camera.

[RobiLee]

I love Moody's Mood For Love and he sings it so well. Loved all of his songs. that he sang on Tuesday also. His voice is so smooth and I find it soothing. There is just something about that boy that just touches my heart.

I'm getting a bit tired of seeing Kat's weepy, doe-eyed father on camera.

Aww, c'mon now, why do you have to take a shot a Kat's dad. He's just a proud papa and there isn't anything wrong with that. Trust me I know the feeling. Every time my son plays his guitar and gets on stage to sing my heart swells and I'm so proud that he even has the courage to get up there and do that. To this day when I walk into our YMCA and see my son's name up there on the swim team record board I get all sappy and want to shout out to anyone passing by that that is my son's name up there...lol. Of course I don't do that though .

[anna_66]

Aww, c'mon now, why do you have to take a shot a Kat's dad. He's just a proud papa and there isn't anything wrong with that.

Thanks Robin, I was gonna say that
We all have our favorite pics but mine is STILL Kat...GO GIRL GO

[caseysmom]

Actually Katherine's father is her only redeamng quality for me...hehe sorry Kat fans...

[Samantha Puppy]

I thought Elliot sang "Moody's Mood for Love" extremely well. But it's the only style of song he can do! I'm not saying Katharine has nailed every single genre, but at least she doesn't sound the same all. the. time. *cough* Elliot *cough* *hack* Taylor *hack* When she just sings and doesn't try to go all diva, she has a beautiful voice. She is a much better fit for the title of Idol than Taylor. Besides the "soul patrol" (lame!), who is going to buy his records? I love blues and old classics, which seem to be his forte, and I wouldn't buy his stuff because I don't think he's anything special. Can he sing? Yes. Does he knock my socks off? No. Does Katharine? She can - "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" was proof enough of that.