American Idol Season 5

[Lobodeb]

I knew it was going to be Elliot. He was good, but his song choices just weren't mainstream enough. Talk about neck and neck!

GO TAYLOR!!!!!

[Roxyluvsme13]

I want Taylor to win!!!
I'm sad Elliot got voted off though.

[RobiLee]

I'm so so sad .

I knew Elliott would go home tonite so I was prepared for it. I hope he has lots of success in the future. I'm a big fan of the remaining two, actually I was a big fan of the last four, so I don't really think I care who wins..lol. However, I do believe that Katherine fits the role of "American Idol" more than Taylor.

[flamepony12]

I'm so disappointed Elliot was kicked off. He was clearly the best singer left.

gah. I'm not a huge fan of Katharine, but if Taylor wins I'll put my foot through the TV.

[molucass]

I'm so disappointed Elliot was kicked off. He was clearly the best singer left.

gah. I'm not a huge fan of Katharine, but if Taylor wins I'll put my foot through the TV.

I'm glad there is someone else besides me that feels that way about Taylor..lol

[jazzcat]

My heart breaks!

[caseysmom]

I want to cry, I couldn't help myself I came and looked here before I saw it on the west coast.

I don't even feel like watching next week I don't care for Katherine or Taylor but I hope Taylor wins so Katherine doesn't.

[Samantha Puppy]

I am glad Elliot got the boot last night, although I would've been equally satisfied if Joe Co- errr, Taylor left too. If HE wins the entire thing, I don't know what I'll do. Maybe not watch next year. I do think that Katharine is the best singer (when she doesn't try to over do it) and fits the image of the American Idol the best.

[shihtzulover850]

I am getting really sick of taylor. If he wins I am going to die. Katherine has to win. I agree with flamepony. I will put my foot through the tv.

[RedHedd]

I'm glad there is someone else besides me that feels that way about Taylor..lol

Me too. I probably won't watch next week as I think the finale is the same night as the LOST finale and I can't miss that!

[DogLover9501]

I'm so disappointed Elliot was kicked off. He was clearly the best singer left.

gah. I'm not a huge fan of Katharine, but if Taylor wins I'll put my foot through the TV.

Ditto!

[joanofark]

WOOT WOOT!!!!! Paaaaaaaarty!!!

I'm SO sorry guys, REALLY! But I do believe it was his time to go.

I like both of the finalists, I'd like either of them to win. BUT, I'm rooting for Taylor.

[molucass]

I don't know why, but I haven't liked Taylor from the beginning.. I don't like Katharine either though... so I'm not really "rooting" for anyone..

Unfortunately I wasn't home last night when they were performing, so I can't comment on that, but I liked Elliot and wish it had been Katharine.