American Idol Season 5

[Samantha Puppy]

I like Katharine. How come it's not okay for her to make note that the judges have been hard on her lately but it has been for past contestants (and don't ask me who, I don't remember, I just know that her comments aren't the first of their kind). I think she did poorly with Elvis week, but those are hard songs for a woman to sing and sing well. I think she did really well with all 3 songs, especially "Somewhere Over the Rainbow".

Elliot was boring. I'd be happy to see him gone tonight.

Taylor must have shows mixed up. I thought this was American Idol and all he does is American Impersonation. He even impersonated Joe Cocker's facial ticks!! Come ON!!! He's got a good voice, but show some originality!

I'd like to see Katharine and Taylor in the finale next week with Katharine winning. I can't see Taylor singing a song about puppies and rainbows, like the Idol producers come up with every year (hello - "Inside Your Heaven"? BARF!).

[jazzcat]

I think Katherine would be awesome if she would quit trying to be a Diva and just sing the song. She tries to make every song that "moment" song and it comes out overdone. I hate the way she sings from a low note up to high quickly. Like nails on a chalk board for me. She needs some serious coaching. I had to laugh at her trying to recapture Fantasia's "Summertime" moment by being on the floor to sing. At least she did sing the second song well and I was impressed.

Like some of the other's though, I don't like her attitude. She really puts me off.

I love Elliott but I think he missed his chance to shine last night, especially with the second song - one of my all time favorites. Too bad, I would have loved to see him in the final two.

Taylor - I'm not a huge fan but I think this competition is his to lose.

[dogzr#1]

I don't like Katharine and I hope she leaves tonight. Like others have said, I don't like her aditude. She thinks she's the best and is perfect and gets sad when the judges say otherwise.

Elliot didn't do the greatest but I hope he goes on. I like his voice and personality.

Taylor did the best out of the three and I hope he wins. GO TAYLOR!!

[Cincy'sMom]

My prediction is that Elliot will go home. I'd rather see it be Katherine, but we'll kow in about an hour!

[buckner]

I think I'm going to cry. Elliott was practically the love of my life!!! (well, to the extent that AI can take it, at least) I was rooting for him all of the way and I felt he'd go home tonight, but I didn't want to admit it.

Noooo!!!! *cries*

[Lobodeb]

I knew it was going to be Elliot. He was good, but his song choices just weren't mainstream enough. Talk about neck and neck!

GO TAYLOR!!!!!

[Roxyluvsme13]

I want Taylor to win!!!
I'm sad Elliot got voted off though.

[RobiLee]

I'm so so sad .

I knew Elliott would go home tonite so I was prepared for it. I hope he has lots of success in the future. I'm a big fan of the remaining two, actually I was a big fan of the last four, so I don't really think I care who wins..lol. However, I do believe that Katherine fits the role of "American Idol" more than Taylor.

[joanofark]

WOOT WOOT!!!!! Paaaaaaaarty!!!

I'm SO sorry guys, REALLY! But I do believe it was his time to go.

I like both of the finalists, I'd like either of them to win. BUT, I'm rooting for Taylor.

[molucass]

I don't know why, but I haven't liked Taylor from the beginning.. I don't like Katharine either though... so I'm not really "rooting" for anyone..

Unfortunately I wasn't home last night when they were performing, so I can't comment on that, but I liked Elliot and wish it had been Katharine.