American Idol Season 5

[pnance]

Elliot: Did reallly well this week with both song.

Chris: Liked the first song, the second was ok

Taylor: Liked the 2nd song, 1st was ok

Kathryn: Didn't like either song.

Who should go: Kathryn

[elizabethann]

Holy cow! What a night!

Taylor - He rocks! What an entertainer! He is composed, cool & fun when he's on the stage. Love him.

Chris - zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. Can you show a little emotion? He butchered the 2nd song. I love that song but he just sang it by the book. He shows no emotion - not even fun!

Elliot - He was awesome last night! What a great voice! I love him!

Kat - Hmmmmm.....I have to give her kudo's for her past performances. But last night she really wasn't that good. I think she was trying too hard. However, you have to give her double kudo's for trying something different.

I voted for Taylor, Elliot & Kat last night (once each). I got through to Kat's line after 15 minutes. It took me about 20 minutes to get through to Taylor's and a 1/2 hour to get through to Elliot's. I think Kat will go home tonight just because I don't think she has a big fan base.

[Daisy and Delilah]

What a great show!! I love Elvis and this show had even me up on my feet dancing! These last 4 are super talented and it's hard to pick who will go tonight. As a matter of fact, I've enjoyed watching this year more than ever. I think Kat will go tonight and I still think that Chris will win overall. I sat on the phone last night off and on for an hour voting like a giddy school girl . I cast all my votes for Elliot. Go Elliot!! And yes, he was on fire last night!

[Laura's Babies]

I have come to enjoy Chris and I think he will be the winner. He has the complete package of a Idol as well as having a great voice. If you just shut your eyes and listen.... his voice is awesome (taking away that eye candy to sway you)..

Taylor, I just LOVE him and his bayou sounding voice. He is loaded with personality and he would make a great Idol too. Those are my two picks still...

Kat has a awesome voice but she needs some training or something. Her voice is not consistant and it sounds like she runs out of wind a lot and hit a wrong note to much.. A little training and she will go far, even without American Idol.

I think all 3 of them are going to be winners when all is said and done, just to much talent for the record companies to ignore.

[joanofark]

Chris rocked at BOTH songs!! I personally LIKED Katherine!! Taylor did okay. My apologies to all of the Elliot Fans, but I thought he sucked . I've never really liked him. I think he's going. (Or at least should.)

Since the beginning I wanted Chris, Kat, and Taylor to be the final 3. I hope I was right!!

[RedHedd]

Elliott completely surprised me last night and got me voting for him He totally rocked!

Chris I loved.

Taylor was Taylor. Everyone loves him, but to me he's just not American Idol material. He's entertaining as all get out, but vocally he seems limited.

Kat - what happened? Usually I love her, but she just didn't bring it last night. She may end up paying for that.

Who will go home? I don't know. The final four are all so talented that I want them all to win.

[Flatcoatluver]

I didn't get to see it last night, I home Kat goes home though!!! Sorry

[rosethecopycat]

Chris rocked at BOTH songs!! I personally LIKED Katherine!! Taylor did okay. My apologies to all of the Elliot Fans, but I thought he sucked . I've never really liked him. I think he's going. (Or at least should.)

Since the beginning I wanted Chris, Kat, and Taylor to be the final 3. I hope I was right!!

Umm....how's that working out for you.

[joanofark]

Umm....how's that working out for you.

Lmbo, uhhhh. Well, Chris DID rock, I STILL personally LIKE Katherine but she should have gone I guess if it's beetween her and Chris, Taylor DID do okay, And I STILL think Elliot sucked and SHOULD have got the boot. (Sorry, everyone!!)

Since the beginning I wanted Chris, Kat, and Taylor to be the final 3. I guess I was wrong! *Pouty Face*

LOL, THAT'S how I'm working out. Thanks for asking!! ROFL.

[rosethecopycat]

Chris rocked at BOTH songs!! I personally LIKED Katherine!! Taylor did okay. My apologies to all of the Elliot Fans, but I thought he sucked . I've never really liked him. I think he's going. (Or at least should.)

Since the beginning I wanted Chris, Kat, and Taylor to be the final 3. I hope I was right!!

Well, if this mis-vote thing turns out to be true, you may have been closer than I thought.
But, look at it this way, if Katharine received a portion (or even all of) Chris' votes, it only 'rocketed' her into 3rd position. That pretty much means that Elliot still got a lot more votes.
I wish they'd had told us who got more votes, Elliot or Taylor.

I believe if Chris is indeed knocked out, his voting alliance will go mainly to Taylor.

[Cincy'sMom]

If you like spoilers, this website has been pretty right on for who is going home each week. This was posted prior to Wednesday nights results, and obviously they were right about the bottom two. You can look there to see how many votes they say everyone got....

http://www.zabasearch.com/ai_stats.php