American Idol Season 5

[*JTM*Coco*pi*Caramel*]

Taylor: He was awesome especially his second song! He is my favorite!

Elliot: He did alright I guess. His second song was better and the judges seemed to like him a lot. He does have a great voice but not a big fan base.

Chris: I didn't find Chris did good at all this week. Both songs were no good.

Kat: I didn't really like the first song and she forgot the words. The second song was better but I agree with Simon, it was beautiful at first then went downhill. I love that song too.

Bottom 2: Elliot and Chris

Going: Prolly Elliot but I don't want him to go.

[pnance]

Elliot: Did reallly well this week with both song.

Chris: Liked the first song, the second was ok

Taylor: Liked the 2nd song, 1st was ok

Kathryn: Didn't like either song.

Who should go: Kathryn

[elizabethann]

Holy cow! What a night!

Taylor - He rocks! What an entertainer! He is composed, cool & fun when he's on the stage. Love him.

Chris - zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. Can you show a little emotion? He butchered the 2nd song. I love that song but he just sang it by the book. He shows no emotion - not even fun!

Elliot - He was awesome last night! What a great voice! I love him!

Kat - Hmmmmm.....I have to give her kudo's for her past performances. But last night she really wasn't that good. I think she was trying too hard. However, you have to give her double kudo's for trying something different.

I voted for Taylor, Elliot & Kat last night (once each). I got through to Kat's line after 15 minutes. It took me about 20 minutes to get through to Taylor's and a 1/2 hour to get through to Elliot's. I think Kat will go home tonight just because I don't think she has a big fan base.

[Daisy and Delilah]

What a great show!! I love Elvis and this show had even me up on my feet dancing! These last 4 are super talented and it's hard to pick who will go tonight. As a matter of fact, I've enjoyed watching this year more than ever. I think Kat will go tonight and I still think that Chris will win overall. I sat on the phone last night off and on for an hour voting like a giddy school girl . I cast all my votes for Elliot. Go Elliot!! And yes, he was on fire last night!

[Laura's Babies]

I have come to enjoy Chris and I think he will be the winner. He has the complete package of a Idol as well as having a great voice. If you just shut your eyes and listen.... his voice is awesome (taking away that eye candy to sway you)..

Taylor, I just LOVE him and his bayou sounding voice. He is loaded with personality and he would make a great Idol too. Those are my two picks still...

Kat has a awesome voice but she needs some training or something. Her voice is not consistant and it sounds like she runs out of wind a lot and hit a wrong note to much.. A little training and she will go far, even without American Idol.

I think all 3 of them are going to be winners when all is said and done, just to much talent for the record companies to ignore.

[joanofark]

Chris rocked at BOTH songs!! I personally LIKED Katherine!! Taylor did okay. My apologies to all of the Elliot Fans, but I thought he sucked . I've never really liked him. I think he's going. (Or at least should.)

Since the beginning I wanted Chris, Kat, and Taylor to be the final 3. I hope I was right!!

[RedHedd]

Elliott completely surprised me last night and got me voting for him He totally rocked!

Chris I loved.

Taylor was Taylor. Everyone loves him, but to me he's just not American Idol material. He's entertaining as all get out, but vocally he seems limited.

Kat - what happened? Usually I love her, but she just didn't bring it last night. She may end up paying for that.

Who will go home? I don't know. The final four are all so talented that I want them all to win.

[rosethecopycat]

Chris rocked at BOTH songs!! I personally LIKED Katherine!! Taylor did okay. My apologies to all of the Elliot Fans, but I thought he sucked . I've never really liked him. I think he's going. (Or at least should.)

Since the beginning I wanted Chris, Kat, and Taylor to be the final 3. I hope I was right!!

Umm....how's that working out for you.

[rosethecopycat]

Chris rocked at BOTH songs!! I personally LIKED Katherine!! Taylor did okay. My apologies to all of the Elliot Fans, but I thought he sucked . I've never really liked him. I think he's going. (Or at least should.)

Since the beginning I wanted Chris, Kat, and Taylor to be the final 3. I hope I was right!!

Well, if this mis-vote thing turns out to be true, you may have been closer than I thought.
But, look at it this way, if Katharine received a portion (or even all of) Chris' votes, it only 'rocketed' her into 3rd position. That pretty much means that Elliot still got a lot more votes.
I wish they'd had told us who got more votes, Elliot or Taylor.

I believe if Chris is indeed knocked out, his voting alliance will go mainly to Taylor.