Between the humane society and breed rescue, I'd take breed rescue most definitely. My family has had too many bad experiences with the shelter and Humane Society dogs in my city...I'm afraid to adopt from them now. They're temperament testing is absolutely awful, if they'd tested Comet he wouldn't have been adopted out at all due to the fact that he was people & dog aggressive.

I'm probably in the minority here, but my number one choice would be from a reputable breeder for sure. Most (if not all) of my future dogs will be from a reputable breeder. I'll probably try adopting a mutt or two again someday hopefully with better luck, but as I said, most of my dogs will be from a breeder. Another reason for me buying from a breeder is the fact that I really only want to ever own Tollers (I'll never be without one) and a couple other breeds.