American Idol Season 5

[Dixieland Dancer]

Come on guys.... you can't possibly know who will get booted off next week when they haven't even sung yet!

I like to hear them sing and then vote accordingly. Chris has a throat problem (not singing from his diaphram) which makes me not want to vote for him.

[.sarah]

I hope Chris leaves tomorrow! Seems doubtful, but I have my hopes up.

[Animal_girl00]

Chris - he has an amazing voice

Kat - has a great voice but somtimes doesnt do to good

Taylor- alright

elliot - HORRIBLE

top two - taylor and elliot

going - elliot


omg i can not believe kellli pickler got voted off two weeks ago!! (BAD CHOICE!!)

[RobiLee]

I thought Elliott was on fire tonite! Goooo Elliott!!

I loved all the Elvis songs so I was really into it tonite . I am a big fan of the remaining four and it is hard for me to see anyone go. I agreed with the judges about Katherine. If we are going by tonite's performance I think she is the one that has to go .

[*JTM*Coco*pi*Caramel*]

Taylor: He was awesome especially his second song! He is my favorite!

Elliot: He did alright I guess. His second song was better and the judges seemed to like him a lot. He does have a great voice but not a big fan base.

Chris: I didn't find Chris did good at all this week. Both songs were no good.

Kat: I didn't really like the first song and she forgot the words. The second song was better but I agree with Simon, it was beautiful at first then went downhill. I love that song too.

Bottom 2: Elliot and Chris

Going: Prolly Elliot but I don't want him to go.

[pnance]

Elliot: Did reallly well this week with both song.

Chris: Liked the first song, the second was ok

Taylor: Liked the 2nd song, 1st was ok

Kathryn: Didn't like either song.

Who should go: Kathryn

[elizabethann]

Holy cow! What a night!

Taylor - He rocks! What an entertainer! He is composed, cool & fun when he's on the stage. Love him.

Chris - zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz. Can you show a little emotion? He butchered the 2nd song. I love that song but he just sang it by the book. He shows no emotion - not even fun!

Elliot - He was awesome last night! What a great voice! I love him!

Kat - Hmmmmm.....I have to give her kudo's for her past performances. But last night she really wasn't that good. I think she was trying too hard. However, you have to give her double kudo's for trying something different.

I voted for Taylor, Elliot & Kat last night (once each). I got through to Kat's line after 15 minutes. It took me about 20 minutes to get through to Taylor's and a 1/2 hour to get through to Elliot's. I think Kat will go home tonight just because I don't think she has a big fan base.

[.sarah]

Wow, I totally called that one. Chris didn't show any versatility. I got tired of him weeks ago. I used to love him but seriously, no matter what song he sings he sounds exactly the same.

Chris looked LIVID!

Don't worry everyone, you can bet he'll have a record deal! I'll probably buy it as long as he doesn't scream at me anymore

Katharine will go next week unless if one of the other two really screw up. I'll be happy if either Taylor or Elliot win, they both have a lot of talent. I predict Taylor winning, though ... Elliot doesn't have as much personality.


Also, I find it really funny that this is the most action this thread has gotten in such a short amount of time. People are going to start boycotting AI now

[Roxyluvsme13]

We all know he'll get a record contract, so I don't see why you all are panicking .

[flamepony12]

I don't care much of Chris being kicked off, but I must say, I would have MUCH, MUCH rather seen TAYLOR kicked off. If Taylor wins I'll be pissed. x_______x

[jazzcat]

Wow, I had expected Katherine to go. Too bad she didn't.

Go Elliott!!!!!!!!!

[Kfamr]

Chris can come and be my idol...

Haven't really been watching it, just coming to this thread for updates. I'll watch the last one.

[zippy-kat]

I'm a Taylor and Kat fan. Kat realllly didn't do all that well last night but still, as a fan, I'm glad she didn't go.

I think everyone was pretty much blown away by tonight's decision. Did anyone else notice Kat's expression? I think she pretty much thought it would be her last night. (As well as most everyone else.)

The final three... things are getting intense!