American Idol Season 5

[Dixieland Dancer]

Elliot wasn't his strongest. I think when he is on, he is really good. I like him a lot.

Paris, I'm tired of her and hope she's the one to leave tonight.

Chris, He sounds the same in all his songs and it gets boring. What I really hate the most is that he sings from his throat and not from his diaphram. He could be so much better if he learned voice control.

Kat, I love her voice when she isn't pitchy. Her first song last night was weak but her second song was great (minus the floor routine).

Taylor... he entertains me and I was laughing out loud with his first song and cheering him. His second song worried me at first but he pulled it off with great vocals. It's hard to do a Beatles tune and make it work (especially when it's such a popular song).

My bottom two are Paris and Elliot (sadly). I hope Paris goes and Elliot has a chance to redeem himself next week.

[.sarah]

Well did we call it right or what? I'm happy that Paris went home finally.

[Lobodeb]

Well did we call it right or what? I'm happy that Paris went home finally.

we ARE good, aren't we?

[CagneyDog]

WOOT
About time

[.sarah]

Who does everyone think is going to win? I think it will be Chris, though I want it to be Elliot or Taylor. I want Katharine to go home next week, but it will probably be Elliot

[pnance]

Who does everyone think is going to win? I think it will be Chris, though I want it to be Elliot or Taylor. I want Katharine to go home next week, but it will probably be Elliot

I think Chris is going to win it. I love Taylor but I think Chris is a better singer. The final 2 I could see being Taylor and Chris, which considering I like both is a win win for me...

[.sarah]

I used to love Chris but I have started noticing that he screams a lot. Oh, and when his voice "rolls", all I heard is "baaaa" like a sheep. Not meant to be offensive, but that really is what it sounds like to me I would probably buy his CD though, unless if his singles are of him screaming - that really annoys me. I do think he is talented, I just think that Taylor and Elliot are better.

[anna_66]

Who does everyone think is going to win? I think it will be Chris, though I want it to be Elliot or Taylor. I want Katharine to go home next week, but it will probably be Elliot

Well who I want to win and who will "probably" win is two different things
I want Kat to win. I just think she fits the part as American Idol better than the others do.
But I think either Chris or Taylor will win.

I really like all the remaining contestants...I wish they could all win!

[WolvesRawk]

I want Katherine to win. I think she and Chris will be the final 2.